Financial Risk Manager Part 1

Financial Risk Manager Part 1

Get started today

Ultimate access to all questions.


A financial analyst is evaluating the historical performance of two commodity investment funds, both of which use the Reuters/Jefferies-CRB Index as their benchmark. The analyst has compiled monthly return data and has decided to use the information ratio (iR) to assess which fund has delivered higher returns more efficiently. The relevant data is summarized in the table below:

MetricsFund 1Fund 2Benchmark
Average monthly return1.488%1.468%1.415%
Average excess return0.073%0.053%0.000%
Standard deviation0.294%0.237%0.238%
Tracking error0.344%0.341%0.000%

Calculate the information ratio for both funds and interpret the results.




Explanation:

The information ratio (IR) is a measure used to evaluate the performance of an investment portfolio by comparing its excess return to its tracking error. It indicates how well a portfolio manager is able to generate excess returns relative to the risk taken, as measured by the tracking error. The formula for calculating the information ratio is:

IR=E(Rp−Rb)Tracking ErrorIR = \frac{E(R_p - R_b)}{Tracking\ Error}

Where:

  • E(Rp−Rb)E(R_p - R_b) is the average excess return of the portfolio over the benchmark.
  • Tracking error is the standard deviation of the difference between the portfolio's returns and the benchmark's returns.

In the provided file content, the average excess returns and tracking errors for two funds are given as follows:

Fund 1:

  • Average excess return: 0.073%
  • Tracking error: 0.344%

Fund 2:

  • Average excess return: 0.053%
  • Tracking error: 0.341%

Using the formula, the information ratio for each fund can be calculated:

For Fund 1: IRFund1=0.000730.00344=0.212IR_{Fund1} = \frac{0.00073}{0.00344} = 0.212

For Fund 2: IRFund2=0.000530.00341=0.155IR_{Fund2} = \frac{0.00053}{0.00341} = 0.155

The higher the information ratio, the better the portfolio manager is at generating excess returns relative to the risk taken. In this case, Fund 1 has a higher information ratio (0.212) compared to Fund 2 (0.155), indicating that Fund 1 has performed better in terms of generating excess returns more efficiently.

Therefore, the correct answer is A: "IR for Fund 1 = 0.212, IR for Fund 2 = 0.155; Fund 1 performed better as it has a higher IR."