
Answer-first summary for fast verification
Answer: No
The solution does not meet the goal because Quantiles binning with PQuantile normalization is an unsupervised method that does not consider the target column. The goal specifically requires binning to predict a target column, which implies a supervised approach. Quantiles binning creates bins based solely on data distribution percentiles, independent of the target variable. In contrast, supervised binning methods like Entropy MDL (Minimum Description Length) use the target column to determine optimal bin boundaries that maximize predictive power. While PQuantile normalization transforms values to a [0,1] range before binning, this preprocessing step does not incorporate target information. The community discussion shows divided opinions, but the most technically sound reasoning (from modschegiebsch with 22 upvotes) correctly identifies that quantile binning is unsupervised and cannot directly support target prediction. The high percentage of community answers (78% A vs 22% B) favoring 'Yes' appears to reflect confusion about the distinction between general data preparation and supervised feature engineering for prediction tasks.
Author: LeetQuiz Editorial Team
Ultimate access to all questions.
No comments yet.
You are a data scientist using Azure Machine Learning Studio. You need to normalize values by binning them into bins to predict a target column.
Solution: Apply a Quantiles binning mode with a P-Quantile normalization.
Does the solution meet the goal?
A
Yes
B
No