
Answer-first summary for fast verification
Answer: If the purpose of the position is designated as hedging (rather than speculation) and if the hedge consists only of some combination(s) of forwards, swaps and/or options--which are the primary building blocks--then the firm can avoid problems suffered by the financial engineering case studies because the firm avoids undue sophistication.
## Explanation Statement D is false because: - **Hedging designation alone doesn't prevent problems**: Simply designating a position as a "hedge" doesn't automatically make it safe or appropriate. The Orange County case involved positions that were likely intended as hedges but were poorly understood and excessively leveraged. - **Basic derivatives can still create significant risk**: Even simple forwards, swaps, and options can create substantial risk if not properly understood, sized, or managed. The complexity of the instrument is not the only factor - the overall strategy, leverage, and risk management framework are equally important. - **Sophistication vs. understanding**: Avoiding "undue sophistication" doesn't guarantee safety. The real issue is whether the firm understands the risks involved, regardless of the complexity level. - **Case study evidence contradicts this**: Both Bankers Trust and Orange County cases show that problems can occur even with relatively standard derivative instruments when combined with poor risk management practices, excessive leverage, or misunderstanding of the underlying risks. Statements A, B, and C are all true and represent important risk management lessons from these case studies.
Author: LeetQuiz .
Ultimate access to all questions.
No comments yet.
Which of the following statements is false?
A
Bankers Trust (BT) proposed an overly complex swap to their clients (P&G and Gibson Greetings) but the swaps experienced colossal losses; the clients sued BT, who never recovered from the ensuing reputational damage.
B
Orange County's treasurer (Robert Citron) borrowed through the repo market to purchase inverse floating-rate notes--positions that Citron later said he did not understand--but the combination of excessive leverage and embedded interest-rate risk generated losses that ultimately forced Orange County to file for bankruptcy.
C
Firms need to understand the risks that are inherent in their business models. Senior management then needs to deploy robust policies and risk measures tying risk management, and particularly the use of derivatives, to risk appetite and overall business strategy as it has been communicated to stake holders.
D
If the purpose of the position is designated as hedging (rather than speculation) and if the hedge consists only of some combination(s) of forwards, swaps and/or options--which are the primary building blocks--then the firm can avoid problems suffered by the financial engineering case studies because the firm avoids undue sophistication.