
Answer-first summary for fast verification
Answer: both to suitability and to loyalty, prudence, and care.
## Explanation Werner Merz has violated **both** the Standards relating to suitability and loyalty, prudence, and care. ### 1. **Violation of Standard III(C) - Suitability** - Merz manages a **short-term corporate bond mutual fund**, but he purchased **long-term government bonds** for the fund. - This represents a mismatch between the fund's stated investment objectives (short-term corporate bonds) and the actual investment made (long-term government bonds). - The suitability standard requires that investment recommendations and actions must be consistent with the client's (or fund's) objectives, constraints, and risk tolerance. - By purchasing long-term government bonds for a short-term corporate bond fund, Merz failed to ensure the suitability of the investment for the fund's stated mandate. ### 2. **Violation of Standard III(A) - Loyalty, Prudence, and Care** - Merz purchased the bonds at **100** when market prices were **below 100**, meaning he paid above market value. - This action benefited the bank (by avoiding a loss) at the expense of the mutual fund investors (who paid above market value). - The standard requires placing client interests above employer or personal interests and exercising prudence and care. - By accepting the bank president's assurance without proper due diligence and purchasing above market value, Merz failed to act in the best interests of the fund's investors. ### Additional Considerations: - The bank president's assurance that "the fund can hold the bonds to maturity and get a full return of the initial investment" does not justify the violation, as: 1. The fund's objectives may not align with holding long-term bonds to maturity 2. The opportunity cost of being invested in unsuitable securities 3. The immediate loss from purchasing above market value Therefore, Merz has violated both standards, making option **C** the correct answer.
Author: LeetQuiz .
Ultimate access to all questions.
No comments yet.
Werner Merz, CFA, manages a short-term corporate bond mutual fund at a subsidiary of Cygnet Bank. The president of Cygnet Bank tells Merz that the bank needs to sell some of its long-term government bond holdings; however, because market prices are below their purchase price of 100, a loss would be realized. The president asks Merz to purchase these bonds for the mutual fund at 100, assuring him that the fund can hold the bonds to maturity and get a full return of the initial investment. Merz purchases the bonds for the fund at 100 as requested. Merz has most likely violated the Standard(s) relating:
A
only to suitability.
B
only to loyalty, prudence, and care.
C
both to suitability and to loyalty, prudence, and care.