Explanation
Let's analyze each option:
Option A: "Balance sheet effects differ based on whether the lease is a direct financing lease or a sales-type lease"
- This statement is incorrect. For finance leases, the lessee recognizes both an asset (right-of-use asset) and a liability (lease liability) on the balance sheet regardless of whether it's a direct financing or sales-type lease from the lessor's perspective. The classification as direct financing vs. sales-type lease affects the lessor's accounting, not the lessee's balance sheet effects.
Option B: "The lessor reports a profit on the sale of the leased asset on the income statement in the case of a sales-type lease"
- This statement is correct. In a sales-type lease, the lessor (typically a manufacturer or dealer) recognizes a profit or loss on the "sale" of the leased asset at lease inception. This occurs because the lessor is effectively selling the asset to the lessee. In contrast, for a direct financing lease, the lessor only recognizes interest revenue over the lease term.
Option C: "A lessee reports the interest portion of the lease payment as operating cash flow under IFRS and financing cash flow under US GAAP"
- This statement is incorrect. Under both IFRS and US GAAP, for finance leases, the lessee reports:
- Interest portion of lease payment: Operating cash flow
- Principal portion of lease payment: Financing cash flow
This treatment is consistent across both accounting standards for finance leases.
Key Concepts:
- Finance leases (capital leases under old US GAAP) transfer substantially all risks and rewards of ownership to the lessee.
- Lessee accounting: Recognizes right-of-use asset and lease liability; depreciates asset; recognizes interest expense.
- Lessor accounting:
- Sales-type lease: Lessor recognizes profit/loss at inception + interest revenue
- Direct financing lease: Lessor recognizes only interest revenue (no profit/loss at inception)
- Cash flow classification: Interest portion is operating cash flow under both IFRS and US GAAP for finance leases.
Therefore, Option B is the only correct statement that accurately describes the effect of finance leases on financial statements.